17. February 2016

Evolution or Revolution? The Innovation Dilemma in the FinTech Industry

Innovation Dilemma in the FinTech Industry

The FinTech scene has been hyped for some years now - media outlets are pushing out article after article about a FinTech revolution and talk of a guaranteed disruption for the financial industry’s existing top dogs: banks and financial operators. But what is the factual reality behind the hype? How and to what extent did FinTech change the financial industry in Switzerland these past few years?

Evolution or revolution? It is the classical question everyone in the innovation business has ended up with when working on promising new technologies. Of course, the underlying hope is to reshape the industry and to provide new ways for the business to better serve customers’ expectations. The FinTech scene has been hyped for some years now - media outlets are pushing out article after article about a FinTech revolution and talk of a guaranteed disruption for the financial industry’s existing top dogs: banks and financial operators. In the eyes of some, FinTech will even replace traditional banking altogether and anyone that doesn’t adapt will inevitably disappear.

But what is the factual reality behind the hype? How and to what extent did FinTech change the financial industry in Switzerland these past few years? Surprisingly, the existing market leaders are still very successful – at least if we look at the figures and numbers in their books.

According to the Swiss Banking Association, the operating net income in 2015 rose by 1.2% to 61.2 Billion CHF. Between 2014 and 2015, the aggregated balance sheet rose by 3.3% to a total of 3233 Billion CHF. Additionally, 86% of all interviewed customers state that they are between “satisfied” and “very satisfied” with the existing services the banks are providing.

At the same time, “True Wealth”, the most active Robo-Advisory platform in Switzerland, predicts that they will be able to reach 1 Billion assets under management by 2017. This anticipated number only represents 0.00015% of all existing assets under management in Switzerland’s traditional banking industry.

As stated by a study conducted by the Hochschule Luzern, the crowdfunding industry in Switzerland has raised around 15 Million CHF in 2014 – an insignificant number when compared to the traditional volume in the small credit industry of 12.5 Billion CHF.

So where is this wave of digital disruption and why should banks worry about the existing FinTech revolution? In my opinion, banks and financial institutions do not fear the competition of startups at all and rather than seeing them as a threat, have instead decided to take advantage of the wave of innovation. They do so directly by making use of the optimization that FinTech can add to their offered services. Indirectly, the rise of FinTech has also started changing the internal organization of traditional financial institutions with consequences such as the closing down of branches.

Going back to the title: the hype around FinTech seems to be an organic evolution of the financial industry rather than a revolution - at least for the time being, at least according to the numbers and at least in Switzerland.

Now, this may sound like I have no faith in FinTech but I assure you, quite the opposite is the case. I’m a FinTech guy and I believe the disruption exists and is applied – the benefit is simply falling inside the system rather than outside. So where is the economical space for a FinTech startup in a country like Switzerland with a small and saturated market? In a follow-up article I will investigate the intrinsic value of Switzerland as a hub for the FinTech industry.


Martin Fabini
Martin Fabini

Martin Fabini studierte Mathematik an der Universität Göttingen und ist seit mehr als 20 Jahren in der IT tätig. Mit einem Hintergrund als Software-Entwickler und Architekt hat er im Verlaufe der letzten Jahre vielfältige Managementaufgaben und Beratungsmandate wahrgenommen.

Related Articles

Handling the Communication Channel Shift to Social Media
How to Mine Gold: Handling the Communication Channel Shift to Social Media

Data being the gold of the 21st century is a given fact by now. Still, most companies do not have a strategy on how to handle social media data, even though it has become the main channel of client communication. To tackle this problem, we recently carried out a ti&m garage with a major Swiss bank.

find more information
More with LeSS: An Interview with Cesario Ramos
More with LeSS: An Interview with Cesario Ramos

Have you heard of the Large Scale Scrum (LeSS) framework, but aren't entirely sure what it is? Are you a Scrum Master who wants to take his knowledge of one-team Scrum to the next level and learn about scaling agile development to multiple teams? Cesario Ramos, Lean & Agile coach as well as certified LeSS trainer, shares his knowledge in an interview.

find more information
2018_09_bewegende software-architektur
Bewegende Software-Architektur: Wie funktioniert Architekturarbeit in agilen Vorhaben?

Heutzutage gilt agile Softwareentwicklung als Erfolgsfaktor bei besonders innovativen und zeitkritischen Projekten durch ihre schnelle Reaktionsfähigkeit auf Veränderungen im Markt. Wie aber ist es möglich, die Software-Architektur so zu gestalten, dass der vermeintliche Widerspruch Nachhaltigkeit versus Agilität, nicht nur elegant gelöst wird, sondern sogar noch zu einer besseren Architektur führt.

find more information
Helsana+ App
Ab in die Cloud – wie ti&m Helsana+ in die Cloud brachte

Das App-basierte Bonusprogramm Helsana+ belohnt gesundes Verhalten und Treue der Nutzer. Mit ti&m und der Cloud machte Helsana dieses fit für die Zukunft. Dazu haben wir das bestehende Back-end komplett neu als cloud-native Applikation geschrieben.

find more information
Robo Advisor Sparkonto 750x410
Warum Robo Advisor an Sparkonten scheitern

Robo Advisor stellen inzwischen keine Innovation mehr dar. Bereits vor über 10 Jahren wurde davon gesprochen und seit 2009 ist der erste digitale Berater in der Schweiz im Einsatz. Bisher wurde aber der physische Berater nicht ersetzt, noch konnte die grosse Masse der Schweizer Sparkontobesitzer zum Anlegen bewegt werden. Wie also können Robo Advisor einen Mehrwert für den Endkunden bieten?

find more information
Schnelle Innovation - wie ist das möglich?
Schnelle Innovation - wie ist das möglich?

Dass schnelle Innovationen in grossen Organisationen möglich sein soll, scheint vielen unmöglich zu sein. Doch Thomas Wüst zeigt mit seiner ti&m AG jeden Tag aufs Neue, dass genau dies möglich ist.

find more information